Private Healthcare in Canada?
Other than the big Canadian victory at the World Cup of Hockey yesterday, a lot of attention is being focused on the First Ministers’ Conference on Canadian healthcare reform. While in front of the cameras premiers are not discussing the option of private healthcare. It’s no wonder, given that polls show that most Canadians are opposed to privatization. Behind closed doors, however, we can be sure that the idea is on the table. In British Columbia the current Liberal government has been repeatedly pushing for the privatization of all kinds of services, including healthcare. Rest assured that Gordon Campbell is negotiating for a deal with the federal government that will allow his government to continue in its plans.
Of course there are certainly good reasons for considering the option of privatizing services. Like any idea, we shouldn’t automatically dismiss the idea without giving it some thought. From the standpoint of lawmakers, privatization makes their job easier by shifting the responsibility to the private sector. The question is whether it is truly in the best interest of the public in the long term. I have my doubts about this.
It is a common belief that private enterprise is the most efficient way to provide goods and services. But before we move ahead on this assumption, perhaps we should test its validity–particularly as it relates to healthcare in Canada. Where are the studies showing that private delivery is best? What do studies opposed to private healthcare have to say? What can we learn from other countries such as the United States on one side of the spectrum, and Germany on the other? The bottom line is that we cannot allow ideology to guide our decisions. It may just be that the market isn’t the solution to every problem. Whatever we do, we must tread carefully because once we start down the privatization road, it will be difficult to turn back.
Posted in Canadian Politics having no comments »