Private Healthcare in Canada?

September 15th, 2004 by Joel

Other than the big Canadian victory at the World Cup of Hockey yesterday, a lot of attention is being focused on the First Ministers’ Conference on Canadian healthcare reform. While in front of the cameras premiers are not discussing the option of private healthcare. It’s no wonder, given that polls show that most Canadians are opposed to privatization. Behind closed doors, however, we can be sure that the idea is on the table. In British Columbia the current Liberal government has been repeatedly pushing for the privatization of all kinds of services, including healthcare. Rest assured that Gordon Campbell is negotiating for a deal with the federal government that will allow his government to continue in its plans.

Of course there are certainly good reasons for considering the option of privatizing services. Like any idea, we shouldn’t automatically dismiss the idea without giving it some thought. From the standpoint of lawmakers, privatization makes their job easier by shifting the responsibility to the private sector. The question is whether it is truly in the best interest of the public in the long term. I have my doubts about this.

It is a common belief that private enterprise is the most efficient way to provide goods and services. But before we move ahead on this assumption, perhaps we should test its validity–particularly as it relates to healthcare in Canada. Where are the studies showing that private delivery is best? What do studies opposed to private healthcare have to say? What can we learn from other countries such as the United States on one side of the spectrum, and Germany on the other? The bottom line is that we cannot allow ideology to guide our decisions. It may just be that the market isn’t the solution to every problem. Whatever we do, we must tread carefully because once we start down the privatization road, it will be difficult to turn back.

Bookmark and Share

Posted in Canadian Politics having no comments »

Law 3 Week 1

September 11th, 2004 by Joel

Well the first week is over. It began without much fanfare and ended the same way.

The first week of Year One was full of excitement—meeting new people, learning the law lingo, lots of free food. This time around it was mostly familiar faces and repeated responses to the question, “How was your summer?”

Hopefully one thing I’ve learned from my first two years is to get to work right away. The term flies by so quickly and it’s easy to let the reading pile up—that is if you intend to do the reading. I try to, but for many courses, there are more effective ways of using one’s time than reading for them…

So the final year has begun. Yet it seems that I was just recently a keen first year student looking for his small group’s classroom. I don’t miss the apprehension and nervousness but some more free food would be nice.

Bookmark and Share

Posted in Random Musings having no comments »

Bush & Southern Baptists

June 16th, 2004 by Joel

Recently, the Southern Baptist Convention received a special address from President Bush via satellite (click here for the article). He spoke about all the right hot-button topics including abortion, gay marriage (or as the sbc website puts it, gay “marriage”) and human cloning. The president spoke of his desire to help create a “culture of life.”

I applaud this goal. We should create a society where life is affirmed and respected. This includes helping improve the lives of those already out of the womb.

Yet poverty and human rights are causes that fail to “energize the conservative base”. Why is this? Perhaps we don’t want to explore our own complicity in the poverty and abuse going on throughout the world. I’m not saying that abortion, gay marriage and human cloning aren’t important issues. But perhaps these issues are given too much airplay. Certainly this is partly because they are relatively new issues and therefore better suited for a news program than the issue of poverty, for example. Yet there may be another reason. These issues are comfortable. Most of us will never be affected by abortion, gay marriage or human cloning. Thus, it is easy to decide where we stand on these issues because it is unlikely that we will ever actually engage in one of them. Conveniently, if we get worked up enough about these issues in society, we can avoid facing the fact that we compromise our ethics all of the time in the way we live our lives. Consider the outrage displayed over the exposure of Janet Jackson’s breast versus the Abu Graib prison torture in Iraq. Are these two incidents anywhere near each other on the ethical spectrum?

Bookmark and Share

Posted in American Politics, Religion having no comments »

Strategic Voting

June 15th, 2004 by Joel

In previous elections there was a problem of vote-splitting on the “right” end of the spectrum. This election the same thing may happen on the “left” side. Depending on which way you lean, this may or may not be a problem. In any case, the way elections work in Canada often gives rise to the need to vote strategically. This is something I am considering. As a result, I wanted to know which way my riding is likely to go so that I don’t inadvertently support a candidate that I don’t want to by helping split the vote. I found this site called www.electionprediction.org which allows you to look up your own riding and see how the votes went last election and what the site predicts will be the outcome this election. I hope this helps you make up your mind for how you will cast your one vote.

The down-side to strategic voting this election is that federal funding for parties next election is based on the number of votes they get this election. Thus, if the party you would really like to support this election has no chance of winning a seat in your riding, rather than voting strategically, you may still want to vote for them so that they can get more funding next election.

Therein lies the conundrum…

Bookmark and Share

Posted in Canadian Politics having no comments »